Withheld LG funds: Supreme Court strikes out Osun's case

Withheld LG funds: Supreme Court strikes out Osun's case

The Supreme Court, on Friday, struck out a suit that sought to compel the Federal Government to release all the allocations belonging to Local Government Councils, LGCs, in Osun State, which it withheld.

A seven-member panel of the apex court, in a split decision of six to one, held that the legal action which was brought before it by the Attorney General of Osun State lacked competence.

In the lead judgement that was delivered by Justice Mohammed Idris, the court held that the LG of Osun state lacked the locus standi (legal right) to activate the original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court on behalf of the 30 LGCs in the state.

Stressing that the Supreme Court could only be invited as a court of first instance to settle disputes between any state of the federation and the FG, the panel held that the Osun LGCs are legally recognised autonomous entities that could sue or be sued.

Justice Idris held that the LGCs were the proper parties to challenge FG’s action, adding that the apex court lacked the requisite jurisdiction to entertain the case.

He dismissed Osun AG’s argument that the suit was a public interest litigation.

Though the Supreme Court upheld a preliminary objection the Attorney General of the Federation filed to challenge the competence of the suit, it however admonished FG to give full effect to its judgement that granted fiscal autonomy to all the 774 Local Government Areas in the country.

Osun State, in the suit marked SC/CV/775/2025, sought 10 reliefs from the court, among which included a declaration that the AGF, who was cited as the sole defendant, is constitutionally obligated to enforce and comply with court decisions that affirmed the existence of democratically elected LGCs in Osun, following an election that was conducted in the state on February 22, 2025.

The state prayed the court to declare that the AGF cannot act arbitrarily and contrary to the subsisting and binding decisions of both the Federal High Court and the Court of Appeal, delivered on November 30, 2022 in Suit No. FHC/OS/CS/103/2022 and on June 13, 2025, in Appeal No. CA/AK/15/2025, respectively, “by unlawfully and unilaterally bequeathing the statutory allocations accruing to the benefit of the 30 LGCs of the plaintiff to its own choice candidates, in total contravention of the extant decisions of the courts aforementioned."

It further sought a declaration that the AGF had no right to withhold, suspend and/or seize the monthly allocations, revenues and/or other funds standing to the credit of the LGCs without lawful justification, especially in view of the fact that the state already had in place democratically elected LGCs.

“An order restraining the defendant from paying and/or causing to be paid the statutory allocations standing to the credit of the 30 local governments in the plaintiff state to the sacked All Progressive Congress (APC) local government chairmen and councillors pursuant to the nullified local government election of 15th October, 2022, whose election and subsistence in office had been annulled by valid, extant, unchallenged and subsisting decisions of the Federal High Court in Suit No. FHC/OS/CS/103/2022 and that of the Court of Appeal in Appeal No. CA/AK/15/2025, delivered on 30th November, 2022 and 13th June, 2025, respectively.

On its part, FG, which argued that no cause of action was established against it in the suit, told the apex court that the Osun state government was only bent on frustrating the APC LG officials whose three-year term in office expired on October 22.

“The state has made it impossible for the officials to function, filing cases up and down to frustrate them from performing their duties.

“Our position is that this is not a matter for this court. This court can only be approached by activating its original jurisdiction as provided in the Constitution.

“We also contend that the plaintiff not only lacked the locus standi but was also involved in an abuse of judicial process" counsel to the AGF, Chief Akin Olujimi, SAN, added.